John Cagle

REALTOR® 

Amelia Island & Nassau County Real Estate Advisor

John Cagle Amelia Island

[email protected] |  (912) 467-8558

Service Area |  Serving Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee, Callahan, Hilliard, Duval County and the surrounding Jacksonville area. 

Buying or selling a home in Northeast Florida is a big decision, and the details matter. I’m John Cagle, a Cabana Lane REALTOR® serving Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee, Callahan, Hilliard, Duval County and the surrounding Jacksonville area.

As a former certified residential appraiser, I bring a valuation-focused approach to real estate. For sellers, that means helping you price your home strategically, avoid common listing mistakes, and position the property to attract serious buyers. For buyers, it means helping you understand value before you make an offer, so you can move forward with confidence.

My background also includes years of digital marketing and copywriting experience for companies ranging from small businesses to Fortune 500 brands. That experience gives my sellers a real advantage when it comes to listing presentation, online exposure, property storytelling, and creating the kind of marketing that helps a home stand out.

Why Work With John Cagle, Amelia Island REALTOR®

I combine local market knowledge, appraisal experience, and practical marketing strategy to help clients make smart real estate decisions. Whether you’re selling a home on Amelia Island, buying in Fernandina Beach, relocating to Nassau County, or exploring options in Yulee, Callahan, Hilliard, Duval County or the greater Jacksonville area, my goal is to give you clear guidance from start to finish.

Real estate can be exciting, but it can also get complicated quickly. Pricing, inspections, negotiations, appraisals, insurance concerns, lender requirements, repair decisions, and contract timelines all matter. My role is to help you understand the moving parts, avoid unnecessary surprises, and make decisions based on real information, not guesswork.

When you work with me, you’re not just getting someone to open doors or put a sign in the yard. You’re getting a local real estate advisor with appraisal experience, marketing experience, and a practical understanding of what helps deals come together in today’s Northeast Florida market.

Whether you’re preparing to sell, buying your first home, moving up, downsizing, relocating, or evaluating an investment property, I’d be glad to help you make your next move with confidence. 

Client Testimonies

"Five stars isn't enough for this Realtor. We had moved 5 hours away to our new home, when my husband Read More Read Less
"John was very helpful. He answered so many questions for me. So grateful."
"John is a fantastic realtor! My wife and I both feel so fortunate to have such a dedicated, kind, a Read More Read Less
"I had an excellent experience working with my realtor and friend, John Cagle. My home sold quickly t Read More Read Less
"I had such a great experience working with John on his Jacksonville listing. This transaction was a Read More Read Less
"I had a great experience with John. He was punctual and professional, but also down-to-earth-- I cou Read More Read Less
"John Cagle is honestly hands down one of the most experienced, kind, informative, knowledgeable, cha Read More Read Less
"John made the process of selling my home very easy. Will use him again on my next sale or purchase."
"John has consistently been communicative, honest, and nothing less than a passionate expert the real Read More Read Less
"John is a ray of sunshine. Bright, warm, and inviting. A genuinely great man with the experience and Read More Read Less

Listings you’ll love

with the expert advice you deserve.

What's my home worth?

Get an instant home valuation by entering your info below. 

    Our latest

    Blog Posts

    Do Inspection Repairs Require a Licensed Contractor in …

    Do Inspection Repairs Require a Licensed Contractor in …

    If you're selling a home in Florida, there’s a good chance the buyer will request repairs after…

    Nassau County Housing Market 2025: Trends and 2026 …

    Nassau County Housing Market 2025: Trends and 2026 …

    If you’ve been following the real estate conversation locally, you’ve probably heard a lot of extremes: “The…

    Do Florida Homebuyers Need Title Insurance?

    Do Florida Homebuyers Need Title Insurance?

    Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or a seasoned property investor, understanding the significance of title insurance can…

    Why Spring Is The Best Time To Sell …

    Why Spring Is The Best Time To Sell …

    Thinking of selling? Now may be the best time. Here's why.We're just a few short days into…

    Contact Me Today

    How can I help you?